PDA

View Full Version : What format do you shoot (Sensor/Film size)



ricktas
02-04-2011, 8:35am
What is your PRIMARY sensor/film format? You can pick more than one!

DAdeGroot
02-04-2011, 10:42am
Had to choose Other as there's no APS-H (1.3x) crop selection. So FF & APS-H here.

Although I guess I could have picked just general APS... Although I read that as 1.6x

mrDooba
02-04-2011, 10:46am
I'm with Dave. APS-H(1.3x) primarily and also FF.

PaulMac
02-04-2011, 10:49am
Full frame digital folks..... Unlike some things, when it comes to sensor size... Bigger is better without a doubt. when you bung 20 mil pixels on a cropped sensor the result is diminished quality especially in the noise dept.

JM Tran
02-04-2011, 10:51am
Full frame digital folks..... Unlike some things, when it comes to sensor size... Bigger is better without a doubt. when you bung 20 mil pixels on a cropped sensor the result is diminished quality especially in the noise dept.

and less amount of light drawn in:)

FF and Medium Format Digital for me. Its really really hard to go back to something smaller......

PaulMac
02-04-2011, 10:59am
Jackie... Did try to message you the other week regarding coming out with you but your box was full. Was in Sydney that weekend. Would love to come and have a play with you ( that sounds just wrong) Pvt message me when u can and clear your inbox. Sorry to put this here Rick... strike it off if you like... :)

Xebadir
02-04-2011, 11:08am
Full frame by preference, since I've been able to afford one and see what it can do (had already been impressed was just a matter of getting one). Will go back to APS-C in times of need, or when I am looking for the advantages of the cropped sensor in terms of focal length.

MarkChap
02-04-2011, 11:27am
You know, I have both 35mm sized sensor (Canon 5D) and APS-C (Canon 7D), whilst I like the full frame goodness, I am not 100 percent convinced that it is the be all and end all or the "holy grail" of digital photography.

I think a good bit of the increased quality from a FF sensor comes from the fact that cameras with the larger sensor are also in the higher end offerings, you don't get a consumer/prosumer grade FF camera

zollo
02-04-2011, 11:38am
I am not 100 percent convinced that it is the be all and end all or the "holy grail" of digital photography.

it isnt. medium format hoses FF(35) for image quality every time, and for me, is nearing digital perfection. just wish I could justify forking out for a system. although there are some good offerings at more level headed prices from Mamiya and co. starting to appear

ricktas
02-04-2011, 1:33pm
Had to choose Other as there's no APS-H (1.3x) crop selection. So FF & APS-H here.

Although I guess I could have picked just general APS... Although I read that as 1.6x

I lumped all the APS ones together, cause there are several of them.

JM Tran
02-04-2011, 6:49pm
I lumped all the APS ones together, cause there are several of them.

as Pentax is 1.5x compared to say, Canon's 1.66x :)

ricktas
02-04-2011, 6:52pm
as Pentax is 1.5x compared to say, Canon's 1.66x :)

Yeah, there are 1.4's 1.55's 1.6's that I am aware of, there could be more. I just though if I started listing each one, the poll gets bigger, so decided in APS only

William
02-04-2011, 7:09pm
Full frame digital folks..... Unlike some things, when it comes to sensor size... Bigger is better without a doubt. when you bung 20 mil pixels on a cropped sensor the result is diminished quality especially in the noise dept.



I'm not greedy. I've only got 8.2 Mil (30D) In my cropped sensor :D Still think it takes a better shot than my sons 50D , A 5D would be nice tho :th3:

JM Tran
02-04-2011, 8:26pm
I'm not greedy. I've only got 8.2 Mil (30D) In my cropped sensor :D Still think it takes a better shot than my sons 50D , A 5D would be nice tho :th3:

I am one of many that prefers the 20/30D sensor over the more noiser 40D and 50D cameras:)

agb
02-04-2011, 9:22pm
Rick, am I mad or do the percentages add up to more than 100?
I make it 146.01%

MarkChap
02-04-2011, 9:32pm
Rick, am I mad or do the percentages add up to more than 100?
I make it 146.01%

People can make multiple choices, so that will skew your additions

Kym
03-04-2011, 9:25am
+1 to Mark's comment

% in multi-choice polls is number of votes / number of voters * 100

Xenedis
03-04-2011, 1:13pm
I've been shooting full-frame digital (ie, digital 135-format) since 2006. Before that, I shot with an APS-C DSLR.

I prefer the larger, brighter viewfinder and the fact that my lenses behave as they were designed.

I can certainly see the advantage of APS-C and APS-H sensors for photography requiring long focal lengths and tight crops without discarding pixels (ie, sport and wildlife), but as I shoot neither, the advantage isn't in my favour.

I've never looked into medium-format digital. Besides not being remotely necessary for anything I'm doing, it's prohibitively costly.

Xenedis
03-04-2011, 1:14pm
am I mad or do the percentages add up to more than 100?

The answer to both questions is 'yes'. :-P

agb
03-04-2011, 7:58pm
Oh thanks.:o

mikec
04-04-2011, 12:40pm
I shoot mainly with my 5D these days and prefer it over the APS offerings, but since starting uni and getting to use the Hasselblads and Rollie's with 6x6 film is making see a whole other world of possibilities.

ving
04-04-2011, 2:25pm
standard croppy whoppy :)

rwg717
04-04-2011, 9:22pm
I'm amazed to see no one (so far) shoots large format film:confused013, I thought there might be dozens of AP members using film at larger than 35mm;)
Richard

ElectricImages
05-04-2011, 12:26pm
There are SIX using medium format film. That is larger than 35mm, and the poll indicates that the number of forum respondents using medium format film is almost 1/10 of total respondents.

Longshots
05-04-2011, 12:40pm
I'm amazed to see no one (so far) shoots large format film:confused013, I thought there might be dozens of AP members using film at larger than 35mm;)
Richard


Umm large format film is traditionally considered to be 5 x 4 inch, 10 x 8 inch etc

Medium format film is generally any film in the 120mm format.

And its also worth noting that the question is what is the PRIMARY format ? So while I dont doubt the respondents to the poll, it would surprise me if there was more than two or three who were shooting medium format film as their PRIMARY format. Having a multiple choice answer is therefore a tad misleading as PRIMARY in this context would indicate first choice, so multiple answers would therefore be confusing.

Analog6
07-04-2011, 6:52am
And who are the other 2 shooting medium format digital?

Ah, JM Tran is one, that's half my question answered.

JM Tran
08-04-2011, 11:59am
And who are the other 2 shooting medium format digital?

Ah, JM Tran is one, that's half my question answered.

using the Pentax 645D on Monday for a fashion shoot hehehe

James T
08-04-2011, 12:13pm
..

And its also worth noting that the question is what is the PRIMARY format ? So while I dont doubt the respondents to the poll, it would surprise me if there was more than two or three who were shooting medium format film as their PRIMARY format. Having a multiple choice answer is therefore a tad misleading as PRIMARY in this context would indicate first choice, so multiple answers would therefore be confusing.

I have a 5D on one shoulder and a 1D on the other at every shoot I go to, I suppose I could go through the EXIF in Lightroom and see which gets used more.. but I thought picking both was good enough. ;)

smylie
09-04-2011, 4:22pm
I am lucky enough to have the 5D full frame (would love the 5D MkII) and have recently graduated from the 30D APS 1.6 crop to the 1D MkIII with a 1.3 crop.