PDA

View Full Version : Do you use noise reduction software?



coolie21
28-01-2010, 6:15pm
I have been looking at noise reduction plug ins for Aperture, however they seem a bit pricey. Dfine for example is almost 2/3 the price of the full Aperture app - for a plug in.

Do you use noise reduction software, is it worth the $$$?

Tannin
28-01-2010, 6:24pm
Of course. No photographer should be without it. A real computer will always be far, far more capable of doing a good job than a little chip in a camera. Turn it off in-camera, do it in PP is a good rule.

Dfine is shockingly expensive. Unbelievable!

Yes, NR software is worth the money ...... if you buy a package that is sensibly priced. The long-established markety leader is Neat Image - http://neatimage.com/ - which seems to be getting a bit dear now at $75. The other well-respected one is Noise Ninja at about the same price.

Kym
28-01-2010, 6:37pm
Yes, but only when needed. I do it in PP using Neat Image.

peterb666
28-01-2010, 6:44pm
Generally I don't need it. Only rarely would I need to use it since moving from compact digital cameras to my current camera. Maybe 1 in 1000 shots!

TheGuru
28-01-2010, 6:50pm
Yes, I always have heaps of noise in the sky of my outdoor HDR's but if I don't need it then I won't use it. As you say, it is expensive but so is everything to do with digital cameras.

jim
28-01-2010, 6:52pm
Neat Image. That or something similar is an absolute must if you ever need to use high ISO. And often useful even if you don't.

Tannin
28-01-2010, 6:54pm
Of course. No photographer should be without it.

Unless, of course, you always shoot at base ISO. So some genres it probably doesn't apply to.

jev
28-01-2010, 7:16pm
Noise control is a matter of good exposure to begin with. I rarely need it, if ever.

I @ M
28-01-2010, 7:32pm
Of course I do, Neat Image is a necessity for any pre cmos sensor Nikon owner like me that occasionally ventures above 400 iso. :rolleyes:

kiwi
28-01-2010, 7:51pm
I suppose interestingly even at low Iso you can still introduce noise, maybe not the traditional sort, using some post processing techniques that I'll then use dfine (I really like nik software) to clean up again

maccaroneski
28-01-2010, 8:30pm
Yes - but in my "package" only (so to speak).

As an NX2 user, options are limited.

ricktas
29-01-2010, 5:23am
I used to use Neat Image, but now use D-Fine (www.niksoftware.com)

bigdazzler
29-01-2010, 8:15am
I use Nik D-Fine as well. All the Nik stuff is a little pricey but it is great software and they have EXCEPTIONAL customer service.

Quick story #1 .. I bought Color Efex Pro 3.0 for $300USD, then bought D-Fine for a further $90USD. I didnt realise at the time they offered a Complete Edition of ALL 5 of their programmes (incl. Silver Efex Pro, Viveza, and Pro Sharpener) for $600USD.

After a quick email explaining the situation and how much Id already spent they quickly cancelled the original licenses and allowed me to repurchase the Complete Edition. I was very happy with that reponse :)

Quick Story #2. In December of last year (2009) Viveza 2 came out. I missed the cut off date for the free upgrade by 10 days from the date that I bought the Complete Package so effectively the upgrade was going to cost me $99USD if I wanted it.

I fired off a quick polite email, and they were more than happy to give me the upgrade for free. Once again, excellent service :)

Sorry for going a little OT .. but its worth mentioning that the service you get from Nik is probably worth paying that little bit extra if something goes wrong. Plus its GREAT software :th3:

Miaow
29-01-2010, 8:21am
I only use it if needed - ie iso 1600 and 800 sometimes. Use the Neat Image plugin :)

Tannin
29-01-2010, 9:19am
Darren, it is things like the service you mention that set businesses apart. Don't apologisde for "going on" - this is really useful information. I will happily pay just about any price for a product if I think it really is te best there is and the service matches.

With that said, with D-fine we are not talking about "paying that little bit extra", we are looking at a product being sold for double the going rate; twice as much as the two established industry leaders are charging (Neat Image and Noise Ninja). That seems excessive, especially as (in my understanding) you only get half te product - Neat Image and Noise Ninja hive you complete stand-alone programs as well as Photoshop plug-insm where with D-fine, you must use Photoshop.

I agree that Nik make high quality products, but comparing my one Nik priduct (not D-fine) with my one Neat Image product, the Neat Image one is of even better quality than the Nik one.

I'be been meaning to try the free trial version of D-fine for a while; largely because I don't see where they get off charging that much for s noise reduction package, and I'm curious to find out what (if anything) it does to justfy the price. I'm a sucker for good software, so I have to be careful doing stuff like that. Winds up costing me money.

bigdazzler
29-01-2010, 10:18am
Neat Image and Noise Ninja hive you complete stand-alone programs as well as Photoshop plug-insm where with D-fine, you must use Photoshop..

Not entirely true mate .. you can buy the Complete Collection plugins for Aperture and LR only for half the price ($299USD) than the Complete Collection "Ultimate Edition" which includes PS compatibility. ($599USD)

See here ... http://www.niksoftware.com/store/usa/entry.php?view=singlepurchase/usa_CC_ps_aa-family.shtml

I agree about the other NR software as well .. Ive had trial versions of both Neat image and Noise ninja. I didnt dislike either of them, probably preferring NN.

dbax
29-01-2010, 11:55am
I use Noiseware http://www.imagenomic.com/nwpg.aspx. It was a necessity with the Oly E300 above iso200. Now that I have the 40D I only use it occasionally.

EDIT, oh by the way I use it as a photoshop plug in

coolie21
29-01-2010, 4:15pm
Well so far a majority consensus for the noise reduction software. I am trying the Dfine trial at the moment, has worked beautifully, but I haven't tried any of the others yet. I can be a bit of a software ##### so will have to be careful that I don't get tempted for the full package like Darren.

The US site mentions an academic discount hmm....

bigdazzler
29-01-2010, 4:38pm
Well so far a majority consensus for the noise reduction software. I am trying the Dfine trial at the moment, has worked beautifully, but I haven't tried any of the others yet. I can be a bit of a software ##### so will have to be careful that I don't get tempted for the full package like Darren.

The US site mentions an academic discount hmm....

You wont regret it if you do ... the software is very handy. I use CEP, SEP (awesome!!), and Viveza a lot. The only one that is really wasted on me is the sharpener. I tend to always gravitate back to PS for that.

swifty
29-01-2010, 4:41pm
I have to admit, I don't use any NR other than in-camera settings. And with those I keep it on the low setting (not NIL).
I tend to shoot ISO 100-400 these days and really only go to 800 if i have to.
When in situations where the required exposure is something like iso 1600, f1.8 1/30, I just accept that there will be noise.
If I underexpose something too much and try to 'fix' it PP, I know there's gonna be unnecessary noise too but basically the photo's a write off for me.

Harves
04-02-2010, 9:32am
Purchased and downloaded a copy of Neat Image last night, had a bit of a play with it this morning, looks like an impressive bit of software. Really like the plug-in for CS4 idea. :th3:

ving
04-02-2010, 9:45am
PSPx2 has 2 built in noise removers. the first is just a once over type job that works really well but can obliterate fine detail entirely, the second is much better in that you can choose areas to remove noise from, size and amount of noise "particles", and also it cn sharpen... very effective.

mikew09
04-02-2010, 10:17am
Noise, tend to get noticeable on the 400D at ISO 800 and 1600. Hardly ever shoot at that ISO so on a rare occasion have wanted to reduce noise but I am still learning PSE 7 and not even sure at how capable it is at removing noise.

I really hope this will become a thing of the past once I upgrade my gear in about 12 months.

Inspired
05-02-2010, 11:20pm
ok this maybe a dumb question...but with the NR software..eg neat image - can you use it on your raw images? or do you do all your processing save as jpeg and then put it through the software?

coolie21
06-02-2010, 12:23am
Well after a few days trying the Nik software aperture plug in package I decided I couldn't NOT get it (thank you Darren, its all your fault :) )

If you are considering this I recommend you google for a coupon. My complete package of ALL the Nik apps ended up costing less than 40 USD an app :D

ricktas
06-02-2010, 8:01am
ok this maybe a dumb question...but with the NR software..eg neat image - can you use it on your raw images? or do you do all your processing save as jpeg and then put it through the software?

Anything you do to a RAW file really doesnt alter the orignal RAW file, no matter what software you use. What you are generally altering is a TIF or JPG rendering of the RAW file. Most of these plugins work as stand-alone or PS add-ons, therefore you will need to be working on a TIF or JPG (PSD and others also), when you use your noise reduction software.

milspec
06-02-2010, 12:41pm
There is an interesting review and comparison of Noise Reduction software here (http://www.prophotoshow.net/blog/2009/02/26/noise-reduction-shootout-straight-dope-comparisonreview/).