PDA

View Full Version : Question about posting



J.davis
25-10-2015, 10:19pm
Just had a look at my latest uploads in the bird forum alongside the originals in their folder on my computer.
Noticed that my sig on the bottom L/H corner is unsharp on the forum and sharp on the computer.
Is there some sort of degradation on upload?

ameerat42
26-10-2015, 3:13am
John. I just looked at four of your latest started threads with pics. I can't see anything wrong with your sig at the bottom
of the images. Can you point to one in particular?

ricktas
26-10-2015, 7:07am
We do not alter the uploaded photos in any way. They are exactly the same size, (dimensions and KB) as they are on your computer. The only thing that could impact them is that you are not saving them in sRGB and most web browsers default to sRGB for display. If for example your images are Adobe RGB, and you upload them, the internet browser assumes they are sRGB and thus that can cause issues with the way they appear.

J.davis
26-10-2015, 9:55pm
Top is a screen shot of Ausphoto and bottom one is my computer. Both sRGB


121047

I can see a difference, is it only me?

ameerat42
26-10-2015, 10:02pm
OK, in your first post you said "alongside the originals". Does this mean the very original pics before you re-sized them for AP?

Or, do you mean the ones re-sized for AP but viewed on your screen?

It seems to me (after looking at the pic in Photoshop at full screen magnification) that the image shown in the upper portion is
of lower resolution than the one shown in the lower part. You can see more jpeg artifacts in it.

Am.

J.davis
26-10-2015, 10:45pm
AM, yes you are right, the original JPEG is lower and the AP modified one is upper.
The original is the same size as the NEF (huge), and LR makes a smaller version of the NEF for AP.

ricktas
27-10-2015, 7:04am
AM, yes you are right, the original JPEG is lower and the AP modified one is upper.
The original is the same size as the NEF (huge), and LR makes a smaller version of the NEF for AP.

You need to compare like with like. Ie compare 2 images of the same size. Rather than a NEF at say 5000 pixels wide with a JPG at 1000. When you resize a photo, the software uses an algorithm to delete all those extra pixels, the result is often loss of sharpness. Check the settings in your JPG saving. Things like reducing the filesize to fit our 250KB, if the original at 100% is 800kb, all affect the way an image looks.

If you upload a photo to AP and then look at the image info, the file is the same size as it is on your computer. KB and dimensions. We do not apply any processing or modification to members photos. The only part of the site where that happens, is in the competitions, where if EXIF remains embedded in the entry, we remove it, to ensure anonymity of entries, but again we do not alter the actual image data, just strip EXIF.

Have you tried a different internet browser, cause another cause could be how your browser is rendering images.

ameerat42
27-10-2015, 8:49am
The lowering of resolution will do that, but I would have to say that the effect is negligible as it appears here.
The only possible fix I would suggest is that you do not put on the signature watermark until AFTER you have
re-sized the image. Then when you use an appropriate sized font it will appear smoother. But you can see the
mucking around that would involve.

I'd say leave it as it is, which is not too bad.
Am.

J.davis
27-10-2015, 9:05pm
The difference in size explains everything, thanks for the assistance.