FakeOrFoto?

[ricktas]

Autodesk have brought out another of their challenges.

View the images and then below the main images, decide which ones are real photos and which ones are computer generated (CG).

http://area.autodesk.com/fakeorfoto/

Post your result % in this thread. I got 59% right

[livio]

Wow how good is this I did slightly better but not much I scored 67%. It just goes to show how good CGI's are getting with ray tracing and vector graphics improving all of the time it is getting really hard to tell the difference. Kind Regards, Livio

[Lance B]

I got 59% as well, or 7 out of 12.

[Speedway]

Another with 59%
Cheers
Keith.

[WhoDo]

75% here. I guess my background in IT and graphics helped a little. I actually erred on the CG side in the majority of those I missed, too! :rolleyes:

[Dittography]

67% for me

[mpb]

75% by me.

[I @ M]

https://dl.dropbox.com/u/9582534/ForF.png

[Wayne63]

67% for me, very hard to pick some of them, graphics have certainly come a long way

[JoPho]

Your ResultsExcellent - you have a good eye!
75%

They all looked like photos to me - I only picked a few as not and that was because they seemed like the most easy to fake!

[Dennis Estigoy]

I am soo Newbie.. . Great FUN.. specially this rainy days!!
50% for me.

[Maxineovelar]

Hmmm i got 50% not bad!!

[fillum]

Well I got 4/12. The only one I was pretty sure was CGI was the laneway one (but it was a photo :(), the rest were pretty much complete toss-ups and could have all been photos as far as I could tell. I looked for small things that I didn't think would appear in a CGI image - obviously not the right approach. I had a few goes just picking randomly and got 67% on two occasions and 50% on the other.

What would really be of interest here is not so much viewers individual scores but rather whether there were any particular CGI images that few people thought were photos.

Certainly some great CGI work there...



Cheers.

[wanderer51]

Another one with 59%...at least it said I had 'A good grip on reality'!....could have fooled me! :)

[andrewvid]

wow, now that's my type of modelling :D
Got 84% here, 10/12

[fess67]

59% for me too

[Roosta]

67% here, some are very well done, and some where quite easy to pick as CGI still.

[flashc]

50% for me...

I really thought the annoying bright out of focus area in the background in one of the images would have been real and I looked for images with clean lines and detail. Why would you want something distracting in a clean computer generated image, but I was wrong.

To produce these images, I guess that they are all based on an original photograph as a starting reference point ??




What would really be of interest here is not so much viewers individual scores but rather whether there were any particular CGI images that few people thought were photos.

How many photos (images) entered into competitions now and into the future won't be real life ???

[snappysi]

84% here, 10 / 12.... must admit quite a few where guesses.... i looked at the shadow areas for the most part to see if it was uniform across the image.

Simon.

[mikew09]

Wow - good challenge. 67% for me but I wouldn't give much credit to my skills - it was a coin flip for a couple

[Rattus79]

I only got 42%

Admittedly, I only looked once and didn't scroll up and down up and down to do it.

That website design is TERRIBLE! How hard would it be to have a full size shot with a fake of foto button beside it or below??!!

[Cris]

84% 10 out of 12, Kind of just went with product shots are cgi and got lucky on some others.

[ricktas]

I only got 42%

Admittedly, I only looked once and didn't scroll up and down up and down to do it.

That website design is TERRIBLE! How hard would it be to have a full size shot with a fake of foto button beside it or below??!!

That is how they used to do them, one per page and you picked and then clicked next. Not sure why they have changed that.

[Cage]

75% for me.

Thought the Gecko looked real but the background fooled me, the Lexus is a GR8 fake and the water drops on the flower didn't look kosher.

[old dog]

I`m a 59%er too. That was a real challenge alright.

[jim]

75% for me, rather to my surprise since I wasn't sure of any of them. Computer Graphics are so good now (in the hands of an expert) that they can look more real than reality. At least to me. I find that a little depressing.

The ones I got wrong by the way were the Lexus, the living room and the street scene.

Completely agree about the poor page design.

[Mark L]

I only got 42%



What do you mean only.
I also got the answer to life, the universe and everything.

[Miyuki]

59% here. It was fun :D

[Boofhead]

67% for me, quite a few guesses. :th3:

[willnixo]

I got 84%, but they all look so real. If no one told me to look for a CGI I wouldn't of known

- - - Updated - - -

- - - Updated - - -


What do you mean only.
I also got the answer to life, the universe and everything.

[AVALANCHE]

Your Results
Excellent - you have a good eye!

75%

[Mark L]

Just for willnixo.

98121

[Rattus79]

don't panic!!!

[ashey]

Well I have a shocking eye 25% 4 out of 12 ripped of again:lol:

[bowjac]

42%. Dang.

[Congo]

50% for me too

[aussieray]

i got 8/12 67%

[Cocoajam]

59% - not too shabby

[Granville]

More good luck than good management. Got the wooden chair and the flower wrong

[peterking]

Bugger 59% :(