Advice needed- Filter for tokina 12-24

[Jaysea]

To the brains trust

I have a Nikon d200 and generally use my tokina 12-24 for landscape photos. I have been thinking about getting some nd filters

One option is a screw in 77mm ND Fader Filters which look flexible without having to purchase multiple filters.

Another option is a cokin filter holder which would also allow me to get a grad ND.

What should I get? If I went for the cokin will the P series cokin Work or do I need to get the z series? Or will both still have problems at 12mm?

Any advice appreciated

Thanks

[ricktas]

at 12 mm, the p series will most likely vignette, by the edge of the holder intruding into the field of view. with the sigma 10-20 te p series is visible in the view finder from about 14mm and wider. go the z-pro system for this alone

[arthurking83]

..... go the z-pro system for this alone

At 12mm the standard single filter Cokin P series shouldn't vignette, but as you seem keen to use filters then do as Rick said and go with the Z-Pro system.

Makes it easier to stack filters as required.